Not So Easy to Define AP to Conventional Parents

by Rita Brhel on April 28, 2011

Share Button

Tonight, I’m going to a parenting class at the request of the facilitator because, as he sees it, I will be able to add some interesting discussion about the topic of parenting, being an attachment parent and all. I reluctantly agreed to go, to at least try out the first day of this series. I am hesitant because, as I told him, I don’t want to get stuck in some AP-bashing session. But I finally agreed, after he spent much time trying to persuade me, because I believe that I may be able to help some parents look at my “different” approach to parenting with new eyes.

See, most parents around my hometown know my children as very well-behaved kids. But they don’t really know my parenting style, because being a stay-at-home parent, most of my parenting style is done privately, in my home. The folks around here only see me and the kids out for brief periods of time, such as at church, the grocery store, the bank, or the doctor’s office. So they don’t necessarily know everything I do that goes into these kids’ behavior. They don’t know that I’m much more involved in my children’s lives than most conventional parents, that AP really isn’t for the light of heart. I say this because AP can’t be done half-heartedly and that it really is an intensive, holistic approach to parenting.

I know that tonight’s parenting class is going to center on discipline, for the most part, and the facilitator is very interested in my sharing about positive discipline and how it can be done without spanking or punitive timeouts. But what he doesn’t know is that AP is about much more than positive discipline, that when I talk to parents about discipline I don’t stop at redirection and teaching. I’m very forthcoming that my parenting approach – and therefore positive discipline – encompasses all areas of parenting.

We know AP as the Eight Principles of Parenting. To a newcomer to AP, the fact that there are eight parts to this parenting approach can simply be overwhelming. People start researching parenting styles and approaches, going to classes and reading books, often because they’re looking for something different from what they’re doing. Something isn’t working, and they’re looking to tweak. Those who finally embrace AP have come to the realization that there is no quick fix – that parenting is very much a multi-faceted program, that as parents you have to be involved in every aspect of that child’s life – from discipline to nurturing touch, from feeding with respect to consistent care, from responding with sensitivity to family balance, and so on. Conventional parents don’t want to hear this. They don’t want to know that to change their child’s behavior, they have to do all this other stuff that they see has nothing to do with discipline.

But as my mother is fond of saying, the truth hurts. If parenting was easy, we wouldn’t need books and experts and classes. There wouldn’t be all this confusion in our culture as to what the best parenting approach is. What makes parenting hard, in actuality, is the conflict it creates in parents trying to find balance in their lives. If parents weren’t so concerned with trying to find a way to nurture themselves, probably in a way they were never nurtured to begin with, they wouldn’t have such a difficult time trying to find the time to nurture their children. We, who do AP, realize this fact, that our need to be nurtured ourselves can’t be “balanced” with our children’s needs to be nurtured, that instead our need is totally separate from their need. We can’t starve our children to make ourselves feel better – we can’t only give our children attention during times of needing discipline because we’re too busy to do it other times. And we can’t only give our children attention during times of needing discipline and expect them to feel nurtured, and therefore be well-behaved, all the time.

Yes, AP is time- and energy-consuming but then again, we’re talking about raising kids here. Shouldn’t they be worth it?

Share Button
Rita Brhel (103 Posts)

Rita Brhel is the Publications Coordinator for Attachment Parenting International and Editor of Attached Family magazine. She is also an API Resource Leader and a WIC Breastfeeding Peer Counselor at Hastings, Nebraska, USA, where she lives with her husband and three children.


{ 13 comments… read them below or add one }

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: